Home / Compare / Marketplaces: Where to Sell
Short answer:
| Etsy | OfferUp | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $0.20 listing fee + 6.5% transaction fee + 3% + $0.25 payment processing (US) | Free local listings; nationwide shipping has been discontinued |
| Free option | No (per-listing fee) | Yes |
| Works with | Global, shipped | Local and shipped, US |
| Best for | Vintage items (20+ years old), handmade and craft supplies | Local electronics, tools and furniture |
| Strengths | + Buyers seek vintage specifically + Higher prices for curated vintage + Collects sales tax for you | + Free local listings + Good for tools and electronics + Simple app |
| Weaknesses | - Vintage must be 20+ years old - Several fees stack up | - Local pickup only (shipping discontinued) - Lowball offers common |
| Visit Etsy | Visit OfferUp |
Etsy allows vintage items at least 20 years old alongside handmade goods, making it an excellent channel for vintage home decor, jewelry and collectibles. Etsy collects sales tax as marketplace facilitator.
OfferUp is a local-first marketplace popular for electronics, tools, furniture and vehicles. It ended nationwide shipping, so it is now strictly a local-pickup channel and a useful second option alongside Facebook Marketplace.
Every marketplace has a different buyer, fee structure and category strength. Furniture sells locally, sneakers go to authentication platforms, vintage clothing to Depop and Poshmark, and almost everything sells on eBay. Most full-time resellers list on 3 to 5 platforms and use a crosslister to keep inventory in sync. Fees change often, so always verify the current fee page before pricing. The deciding factors usually come down to each tool's standout strength (for Etsy: buyers seek vintage specifically; for OfferUp: free local listings) weighed against its main drawback (vintage must be 20+ years old versus local pickup only (shipping discontinued)).
Still undecided? See Etsy alternatives or OfferUp alternatives.
Marketplace Pricing Cheat Sheet ($7)
Fees for 8 resale platforms, max-buy and ROI formulas, comp check, net payout table and shipping reference on 6 printable pages.
Listing Templates Kit ($9)
16 copy-paste listing templates and 23 buyer message scripts that help items sell faster on any marketplace.
Instant digital downloads sold via Gumroad.
Checked 2026-10-17. Confirm current pricing on each site.